What is an energy access tier, and how does night-light data relate to it?

A river winding through a mountain valley with a small village and terraced slopes.

If you work on electrification lending, you've run into the Multi-Tier Framework (MTF) sooner or later. It's the measurement standard that the World Bank and ESMAP built to replace the old binary question, "connected or not," with something closer to how a household actually experiences power.

The six tiers, briefly

MTF scores access on a scale from Tier 0 to Tier 5, based on seven attributes: capacity, availability (hours per day and evening), reliability, quality, affordability, legality, and health and safety. A household can have a wire running to the house and still sit at Tier 1 if supply is a few hours a day with frequent outages. Tier 5 means near-continuous, high-capacity, reliable power that meets all seven attributes.

For portfolio work, "percent electrified" numbers from national utilities often just mean "has a grid connection," which collapses tier 1 and tier 5 households into the same statistic. Two settlements can both show 100% connection rates and sit in completely different places on the tier ladder. The MTF survey is the instrument built to tell them apart. It asks households directly about hours of supply, voltage problems, and billing, then scores each attribute and rolls it up into a composite tier.

The catch is cost and timing. A proper MTF household survey takes enumerators, sampling frames, and months of fieldwork. Most programmes run one at appraisal and one at completion, maybe a midline if the project is long. Between those rounds, a task team has no instrument at all. In that gap, feeder lines get commissioned, households connect, shops stay open later, and none of it gets measured until the next survey window opens.

What night-light intensity can and can't tell you

Night-light intensity, the thing we track at Electrification Map, is a different kind of signal. It's a monthly panchromatic read over settlements, at 250-meter-or-coarser resolution, showing where lit area is spreading and where it's flat or retreating. It correlates with grid extension and with the kind of nighttime economic activity that comes with reliable power: shops staying open, workshops running a second shift, streetlights going in along a new feeder line.

What it doesn't do is score the seven MTF attributes. A satellite can't ask a household how many hours of supply it got last week, or whether the connection is metered and legal, or whether voltage spikes have burned out a fridge. Those are survey questions, and night light is no substitute for the household instrument. A settlement showing a steady rise in night-light intensity month over month is plausibly moving up the tier ladder, but the only way to confirm it landed at Tier 3 versus Tier 4 is still the survey.

Where this fits between surveys

The honest use case sits in the gap between surveys, where the next MTF round is a year or two off and the task team has no instrument running at all. If your programme area shows rising light intensity three months after a feeder line was commissioned, that's an early read that households near the line are running lights and appliances after dark, worth a field visit or worth flagging in a progress report ahead of the midline. If the area stays dark a year after disbursement, that's worth asking the implementing agency about just as much, maybe more.

Tier 1 and Tier 5 settlements can look identical on a connection-rate spreadsheet, both just "electrified." From space they don't. A Tier 1 area with a thin, intermittent supply tends to show faint, flickering light that barely climbs over time. A Tier 5 area shows denser, steadier light that keeps intensifying as businesses and streetlighting come online. That's a pattern, not a score, and it tells you where to look harder, not what number to write in the results framework.

For teams tracking grid-extension progress on financed projects between formal survey rounds, that's exactly the gap Electrification Map was built to cover: a monthly light-intensity read over your programme area, so a stalled rollout shows up in your inbox instead of in next year's completion report.

If your next MTF survey is still a year out and you want a monthly check on what's happening on the ground in the meantime, that's worth a look.

Start a project

Back to the blog