Monitoring a power sector loan between ICRs

Dirt road through farmland lined with wooden power poles and overhead lines, hills in the distance.

A power sector loan rarely sits still between the appraisal document and the Implementation Completion Report. Civil works finish, transformers get energized, feeder lines get strung across districts the results framework only mentions in a table. The problem is that most of what you'd want to know in year two or three of implementation simply isn't written down anywhere yet.

Implementation Status and Results reports get you twice-yearly disbursement figures and a traffic-light rating on the PDO indicator. Aide-memoires from supervision missions add color, assuming a mission actually goes to the project area that quarter and not just to the executing agency's office in the capital. Between those documents, a loan that's 60% disbursed against "number of households connected" can go quiet for a year at a time. The ICR, when it finally lands, reconstructs the story after the fact, often from the same household survey data that was going to lag the project by years regardless.

Where the official record runs out

The results framework for a grid extension component usually has one or two connection-count indicators, reported against a baseline survey that was fielded before disbursement started and a completion survey that won't happen until closing. In between, the task team relies on whatever the implementing utility reports back, which is uneven: some utilities track connections by feeder and report monthly, others roll it up annually if at all, and procurement delays on transformers or poles don't always get flagged until a mission asks directly.

None of this is a failure of the M&E design. It's just that connection counts are expensive to survey and the executing agency has other things to do than produce them quarterly for a lender's convenience. So the portfolio team ends up with a results framework that's accurate on completion and largely silent for the three or four years before it.

A proxy you can check monthly

Night-light intensity over a settlement is a rough but honest proxy for grid presence. Where distribution lines go live and connections get made, lit area and brightness tend to increase, visible in satellite imagery that doesn't depend on the executing agency filing anything. It won't tell you a connection count, and it won't substitute for the household survey the results framework calls for. What it does is flag, month to month, whether light is spreading across the settlements in your programme area or whether a component that was supposed to be energized eighteen months ago still looks dark from orbit.

Electrification Map is built around exactly that gap: a monthly panchromatic read over the settlements in a financed programme area, so a portfolio economist has something to check between missions instead of waiting on the next ISR cycle. The useful role it plays sits alongside the completion survey rather than instead of it, a way to notice in month fourteen, rather than at closing, that the component in the northern region hasn't moved while the one in the south has lit up block by block.

Using it for supervision, not for the results framework

The practical use case is narrow and worth stating plainly: flag divergence early, raise it with the task team or the implementing utility, and decide whether a site visit or a data request is warranted before the next mission is scheduled. The function here is to trigger a question, something you raise in an internal note or a mission-prep email, not a number you report upward as a PDO indicator. A reviewer who sees "night-light intensity increased 12% over the programme area" in a results framework should ask where that number came from, because it isn't the connection count the loan agreement specifies.

Used that way, a monthly light-intensity layer earns its place in a supervision routine without pretending to be something it isn't. You get a check between the paperwork, which for a power sector loan is usually a two-year wait.

If that's the gap in your own supervision routine, the Electrification Map offer is built around exactly that interval.

Start a project

Back to the blog